Chinese Censors Douse Lights on YouTube

China reportedly has blocked access to YouTube without providing Google, which owns the video-sharing site, with any official explanation — or even confirmation that it has indeed turned the site dark.

It’s suspected that the government objected to recently uploaded videos of Chinese police beating Tibetan monks during last year’s uprising. China has blocked access to YouTube in the past on similar grounds.

China’s silence on the access blockage is standard operating procedure, according to Usha C. V. Haley, an Asia fellow at Harvard Kennedy School and author of the forthcoming book, New Asian Emperors: The Business Strategies of the Overseas Chinese.

The publication of a film clip of Chinese police beating Tibetan monks, she told TechNewsWorld, would give China’s government more than ample reason for censorship.

Iron Grip

It is little secret that China maintains a tight grip on its citizens’ access to information. The country uses tens of thousands of censors to monitor content availabile for viewing within its borders, whether it’s published internally or comes from outside sources.

Yet, if history is any guide, China will reopen access to YouTube either when the controversy reaches a boiling point or when the offending material is removed — or simply when it feels it has made its point.

The Chinese government’s relationship with Web 2.0 technologies has been a coy one; the country has appeared to be comfortable, at times, with the flood of information the Internet delivers to its citizens — only to abruptly shut off access when a Web site inflames one of its sensitive touch points.

Tibet is oftentimes that touch point, but anything that threatens China’s perceived control over its citizenry is fair game.

When it hosted the Olympics last summer, for example, Chinablocked access to Apple’s iTunes, presumably in response to the addition of a pro-Tibet album to the much-trafficked online store. Several Chinese Olympic athletes had reportedly downloaded the album, which was an embarrassment to the government.

China has alsoblocked access to Wikipedia in the past — supposedly over entries on Tiananmen Square — but then loosened its grip.

The Chinese government has mounted successful lobbying efforts in the past, persuading Google to remove offending material from the Chinese version of the search engine.

Indeed, China is not at all shy about using its market heft to browbeat foreign companies into complying with its Internet policies. A few years ago, Yahoo provided Chinese authorities withidentifying information connected to an email address, which exposed the author of anonymous blog postings about the Tiananmen Square massacre. A human rights organization subsequently filed suit against Yahoo alleging that its cooperation with the Chinese government resulted in the torture and 10-year jail term of Wang Xiaoning.

Central Server

China is able to cut off access to certain sites because the Internet is routed to central servers that it controls, said the Kennedy School’s Haley.

In addition to its human censors, China also maintains a very sophisticated content filtering system — although its mechanics are a matter of speculation.

There are several technologies China could be using to filter content, such as extensive use of firewalls, said Christopher Ciabarra, a security consultant with Network Intercept.

“All traffic runs though a firewall-like box, and they just block all IPs (Internet addresses) of YouTube,” he told TechNewsWorld. “Another possibility is content-filtering machines. “Most likely, they use this method since it is the most common.”

Such behavior is not specific to China. “There are many countries in Asia and outside of Asia that have such controls over the Internet,” Haley pointed out.

Turkey and Bangladesh have both blocked access to YouTube in the past, she noted.

There are ways to work around such blockages, but they’re reserved for those who are technically savvy — and very brave, considering some of the penalties.

Scan-on-the-Go Secure cards can encrypt traffic, thus eluding censorship from a government or ISP (Internet service provider), Ciabarra said. “Also, someone can get a connection around the country — like dial-up to the United States — to connect online.”

2 Comments

  • "Still, there are ways to bypass the country’s great firewall, such as calling a dial-up access number in the U.S."

    Yes, dial-up aross the world seams clearly the solution for youtube. But wait, it’s not a normal dial-up, it’s a *to the US* ubber dial-up.

    "Doesn’t require all that much tech savvy, but a person’s got to be highly motivated — and very brave — to go that route. Catching the latest vid on YouTube won’t be worth the risk for most of China’s population."

    Highly motivated, oh damn yes, it’s danger zone. I’m in china now, I have proxy.org in my bookmark, I look over my shoulder, shaking in fear.

    "won’t be worth the risk", oh damn no. Anyway I’m not that brave considering it’s more risky to download the latest Britney Spears in the US, than talking Tibetan stuff in china.

    Erika Morphy, you are a truly good journalist. To bad your are not ban in china.

  • Wow that is amazing since I have a Scan-on-the-Go Secure card I did not know it would get me past gov security! Nice so no one can watch what I am doing:) I like that! oh and by the way anyone can use these cards not just techy people they are so easy! Just plug them in any USB port and go. No other work is necessary browser opens up and it works like a champ! So easy everyone in China should have one;)

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

LinuxInsider Channels