Why Doesn’t Linux Dominate in the Developing World?

There’s no doubt FOSS is steadily gaining popularity in government circles, as evidenced most recently by the United States White House’s own decision to adopt — and even contribute back to — open source Drupal.

A proposal from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, meanwhile, suggests that certain regulation-mandated submissions should be required to be written in Python for better consistency and interpretability, as Heise Online points out.

Then, too, there are all the various reports of governments, including North Korea, Canada, Cuba, Russia and Vietnam embracing free software as well.

‘A Long Way to Go’

It is in the developing world, though, that many see FOSS’ greatest immediate potential, largely for its low price and minimal resource requirements.

Therein, however, lies a paradox.

“Using my country Ghana as an example, I can say with reasonable certainty that Linux in the developing world, to put it nicely, has a long way to go,” wrote sinaisix on the Ghabuntu blog. “You probably might have read in the news about how the government of some country in Latin America or Asia is switching to Linux or Open Source in general which might sound great, but in reality however, it has very little bearing on the use of Linux among the everyday people.”

Bandwidth Issues

Windows dominates PCs in developing countries, sinaisix asserted, largely through the prevalence of pirated versions. Bandwidth constraints also make downloading Linux a problem, he added.

“This leads me to wonder if there is any initiative anywhere to the effect that the Linux community in the ‘well to do’ parts of the world come together to make as many copies as they can of their respective distros and send them to potential user communities in developing parts of the world,” sinaisix suggested.

It wasn’t long before the topic caught the attention of Glyn Moody,who recently posted his own take on how to solve the problem.

‘I Would Be Willing to Mail an Install CD’

Other bloggers, meanwhile, were soon chiming in with thoughts of their own.

“This is where projects such as the Freedom Toaster comes into play,” wrote Darlene Parker in the Ghabuntu comments, for instance. “It addresses the very issue you describe, as it does take a large chunk of managed bandwidth to download the ISO.”

Alternatively, “I would be willing to mail an install CD to anyone in the world who needs one if I could have a reasonable assurance that it would be used and shared,” asserted stlouisubntu. “All we really need is a community website where one can request a CD and another can respond to the request.”

Given how much free and open source software can offer those in the developing world — as in wealthier nations — the topic struck Linux Girl as an important one. What is the problem here, she couldn’t help but wonder, and what can be done?

‘The Thesis Is Wrong’

“The thesis of the Ghabuntu article is wrong,” blogger Robert Pogson asserted.

“The counter-example is copying M$’s CDs,” he added. “The GNU/Linux CDs can be copied for the same price. All it takes is one download to make many CDs. If they cannot download, do they need a networked OS?”

That said, “I would ship a case of Debian CDs anywhere in the world if it would help,” Pogson told LinuxInsider. “I will do something like that right here in Canada where folks can download but may not know how to burn a CD image.

“Can these folks buy naked PCs? They are lucky if that happens,” he added. “Most of the world is forced to buy PCs with that other OS installed.”

‘More Software Runs on Windows’

Linux isn’t taking off in the developing world for “probably the same reasons it isn’t taking off here,” Slashdot blogger hairyfeet told LinuxInsider.

“One: Windows is easy to pirate, so the whole ‘Linux is free’ bit doesn’t actually hold any water,” he asserted. “There is a good reason why old Bill said, ‘If they are gonna pirate, I want them to pirate from us.’ It creates users familiar with your product who will hopefully be able to buy your product later.”

The second reason is software, hairyfeet said: “Everyone wants to run the same things that everyone else does, and if it is free thanks to piracy, why bother with Open Office when you can get MS Office, or Gimp when you can have Photoshop? No matter how Linux users want to spin it, there is simply more software that runs on Windows.”

‘Windows Updates Are Free’

Then, too, there’s what hairyfeet calls the “PITB factor: Sure Linux is great IF all your hardware is supported and IF no updates bork anything, but I find that about as likely as WinME machines that don’t crash,” he said. “And if something DOES go wrong? Oh Lord have mercy upon your poor tortured soul, because you are gonna spend more time in CLI hell applying ‘fixes’ than you ever will using the PC!”

Finally, there’s also “a little point I bet most Linux users don’t even know,” hairyfeet added. Namely, “if your ISP has caps, ask them if Windows updates count?” he suggested. “Guess what — they don’t, but Linux updates do.

“So when bandwidth caps come to your area, be prepared to pay more for using Linux, folks, because Windows updates are free,” he asserted.

‘Inertia Rules!’

Then again, “it’s certainly NOT the bandwidth problem,” asserted Barbara Hudson, a blogger on Slashdot who goes by “Tom” on the site.

“The poster says that people have no problem copying Windows and other software CDs, so it’s not like everyone would have to use up their monthly 1-gig bandwidth allotment to grab a distro,” Hudson explained. “Just find someone who already has it, and make a copy.”

The real root of the problem is quite simple, Hudson asserted. Specifically, “most people:

  1. don’t know that there are alternatives;
  2. aren’t interested in learning about alternatives;
  3. are already psychologically invested in Windows and don’t want to have to throw out what they’ve learned;
  4. are already physically invested in Windows and don’t want to have to discard all that pirated software ‘that’s worth thousands of dollars’;
  5. ‘need’ Windows for a printer/scanner/other hardware;
  6. ‘need’ Windows for one particular piece of software;
  7. ‘need’ Windows because their school/boss says so;
  8. ‘need’ Windows ‘security’ because ‘linux won’t run my antivirus’;
  9. don’t see a financial opportunity in open software;
  10. are afraid to try something different.”

In other words, “it’s a law of physics,” Hudson concluded. “Inertia rules!”

‘We Can Do More’

Linux will likely gain more traction as Microsoft becomes more effective at stamping out piracy, Montreal consultant and Slashdot blogger Gerhard Mack pointed out.

Nevertheless, “we can do more,” he said. “Sending a lot of installation cds is one idea, but it makes me wonder if we need to be more effective at creating downloadable security update cd images as well.”

For Chris Travers, however, the premise that FOSS is suffering in the developing world doesn’t ring true.

“It’s doing better in the developing world than folks think,” said Travers, a Slashdot blogger who works on the LedgerSMB project and has spent many months in Indonesia and Ecuador. “However, one important element here is that people are conditioned to distrust inexpensive/free (gratis) software due to anti-piracy efforts.”

‘Every FOSS Consultant Is Doing Well’

The major issue holding back FOSS in developing countries, in Travers’ experience, is simply a lack of expertise, he said.

“There are more Windows consultants than Linux consultants,” he explained. Also, “the lack of good vertical applications hurts somewhat.”

FOSS will, however, get there in the end, Travers opined.

“LedgerSMB is used in every continent except Antarctica,” he noted. “Every FOSS consultant I know in the developing world is doing pretty well.”


  • I run a company called Comp_Acct that promotes open-source in Nepal. I have no doubt that it’s inertia that runs the show. It’s very difficult to convince someone who’s familiar with only one thing to stop using and learn something new. Especially when you’re dealing with a whole company of someones who have a hard-drive full of documents in proprietary formats.


    Comp_Acct <>

  • I do need to ask, have the people whom responded to the comments about bandwidth etc ever been in a developing country??? Please leave your desks in North America or Europe and see what reality truly is.

    Even using Skype can be a challenge with bandwidth. As well, given that many locations are still using satellite internet, there are Fair Access Policies in place which limit the ISO download.

    I too have worked in Ecuador, and it is the same there as well.

    As for the assertions that MS is the answer as there is so much more software that runs on it, no matter how Linux people spin it, give me a break!!

    If you have a budget of $35 per year for a rural school student, purchasing licensed software is not a reality, and there is a wealth of programs for education.

    I have worked exclusively with open source programs such as Open Office, Gimp, Thunderbird and haven’t missed a beat.

    Finally, Open Source is making a difference in the developing world despite Microsoft buying/bribing their way through governments.

    • you DO know that ALL the FOSS worth having has Windows ports, yes? Or that employers want employees that know how to run the latest MS Office and make Excel sheets NOT how to hack kernels, yes? Or that JUST LIKE Apple, who often sells gear MUCH cheaper to schools, MSFT does the same? It is called competition, if you don’t like it sorry, that’s is the way of the world.

      That does NOT change the facts, here are a few-FACT-MSFT OSes have ridiculously long lifespans, while most distros are lucky if you get 3 years of support. That equals a LOT more bandwidth which you pointed out they can’t afford. Can’t have it both ways now.

      FACT- Driver support in Linux SUCKS. Sorry, but it is frankly shameful. Devices that work in distro Foo are borked in distro Foo+1 and that is pretty much SOP, since nobody wants to waste time with QA and bugfixes. When your coders work for free, the lousy jobs just don’t get done. Windows is "install disc, clicky clicky" and you’re done. That adds up to again more bandwidth and more support. And I haven’t seen Windows bork hardware with a driver update in years. can you say the same?

      Sorry but nobody wants Linux here, and I doubt it will change over there thanks to rampant piracy making Windows "free as in beer" which honestly is Linux’s only real selling point ATM. It is still to buggy when it comes to drivers, updated at an insane pace instead of spending time on QA, and still requires WAY too much CLI to keep running.

  • is the content to end user system Schoolux, that at least seems promising. With their live hybrid educational platform in both as a being a live CD/USB and a decent digital laboratory. Still their educational content is missing at their site and its no information about legal matters. Still it stands out as the most stronger one.

  • I really just think Linux is harder to use. I have tried several flavors of Linux over the years. Yes, it is getting better. But its still nowhere close to what Windows or OS X can provide for ease of use and installing software, hardware and peripherals.

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

More by Katherine Noyes
More in Community

LinuxInsider Channels